The Pros and Cons of Self-Management vs. Hiring a Co-Host

What Every Short-Term Rental Owner Should Know

Owning a vacation rental on the lakeshore can be incredibly rewarding — but managing it? That’s where things can get tricky. Between guest messages, cleanings, turnovers, pricing, and property maintenance, the demands can pile up fast.

So what’s the best approach: self-managing, hiring a co-host, or going fully hands-off with a property manager? Here’s what to consider — and how to choose the right fit for your goals.

🛠️ Self-Management: The DIY Route

Pros:

  • Keep more of your earnings
  • Total control over guest experience
  • Direct communication with guests and vendors
  • Flexible to make quick changes

Cons:

  • Time-consuming (messages, cleanings, restocking, emergencies)
  • Constant availability required — even on weekends and holidays
  • Harder to scale or step away
  • Risk of burnout and overlooked details

Best for:
Local owners with the time and skills to manage bookings, cleanings, and guest support — and who enjoy being hands-on.

🤝 Hiring a Co-Host: Get Help, Keep Control

What it is:
A co-host assists with day-to-day tasks while you retain ownership and decision-making power. Services can range from guest messaging to pricing optimization, vendor coordination, and more.

With VCoHost, our virtual co-hosting service handles 90% of the work — including guest communication, dynamic pricing, custom guidebooks, listing optimization, and vendor scheduling — all at a fraction of the cost of full-service management.

Pros:

  • Retain control and visibility
  • Low cost (VCoHost charges just 10%)
  • Free up time while staying involved
  • Ideal for experienced owners or those who live nearby

Cons:

  • Still responsible for some on-the-ground logistics
  • You may need to coordinate cleanings, restocking, or emergency calls

Best for:
Owners who want support without giving up control or profits.

🏡 Full-Service Property Management: Hands-Off & Hassle-Free

What it is:
A full-service manager takes care of everything — from guest communication and dynamic pricing to turnovers, restocking, maintenance, and more.

Sans Souci Hospitality offers boutique, white-glove property management for select vacation rentals in West Michigan. We deliver a seamless experience for both owners and guests — handling every detail so you can truly relax.

Pros:

  • Completely hands-off
  • Professional, consistent service
  • Strong guest reviews and operational oversight
  • Ideal for out-of-town owners or high-end properties

Cons:

  • Higher fees (typically 20–30%)
  • Less direct control over the day-to-day

Best for:
Busy owners, out-of-area investors, or anyone who wants true peace of mind with a professionally managed experience.


🔍 So… Which Is Right for You?